The existence of a link between some cases of familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (FALS) and copper-zinc superoxide dismutase (CuZnSOD) has been understood for almost a decade. However, beyond the fact that mutations in CuZnSOD cause FALS by a toxic gain of function, the mechanism whereby specific mutations in the protein structure result in development of the disease has remained almost a complete mystery to date. We have undertaken a critical survey of in vitro characteristics of over 30 of the 90 different CuZnSOD mutant proteins that are known to cause FALS in order to determine the differences that exist between mutant and wild-type properties. As-isolated metal content analysis, SOD activity assays, and thermal stability determinations of a significant fraction of the mutants show that the FALS mutant SOD proteins can be classified distinctly into one of two groups. Members of the first group, termed wild-type-like, have physical properties and enzymatic activities that are strikingly similar to those of wild-type CuZnSOD. The second group, however, show aberrant metal content in the as-isolated forms, compromised SOD activities, and unusual DSC thermoscans. All mutations in the members of this second group occur in or near the metal binding sites of the protein and thus they are termed metal binding region mutants. We have also compared the relative rates of self-inactivation caused by reaction of the wild-type protein and several FALS-linked CuZnSOD mutants with hydrogen peroxide, as a measure of relative peroxidative activities. Results and implications of the role of CuZnSOD in FALS are discussed.