Pepsin-solubilized collagen I from skin and bone was analyzed with regard to its thermal stability as a triple helical molecule in solution and after in vitro fibril formation. Collagen I from human control bone was compared with samples showing deficiencies or surplus in the degree of hydroxylation of lysine. The helix to coil transitions were studied by circular-dichroism measurements and limited trypsin digestion. Melting of fibrils from standardized in vitro self-assembly was investigated turbidimetrically. Human control bone collagen I has a maximum transition rate (Tm) at 43.3 degrees C in 0.05% acetic acid. This is 1.9 degrees C above control skin (Tm = 41.4 degrees C), most likely, due to a higher degree of prolyl hydroxylation--0.48 in bone vs. 0.41 in skin collagen I. Lysyl overhydroxylation of human and mouse bone collagen I appears to reduce the Tm slightly (approximately 1 degree C). Underhydroxylated bone collagen has a Tm which is 2 degrees C below control. Melting temperatures of in vitro formed fibrils are an indication for higher thermostability in parallel with an increase of lysyl hydroxylation. Accordingly, the melting temperature of such fibrils from human control skin, 49.3 degrees C, exceeds control bone by 1.4 degrees C. The degree of lysyl hydroxylation in these samples is 0.14 and 0.10, respectively. Further underhydroxylation (0.06) reduced it down to 45.4 degrees C, while extensive overhydroxylation did not continue to increase the thermal stability of fibrils.