Severe fetal hydrocephalus with and without neural tube defect: a comparative study

Objective: To describe the main perinatal and 1-year outcomes in babies with a prenatal ultrasonographic diagnosis of severe hydrocephalus according to the presence or absence of a neural tube defect (NTD) in a country where abortion is illegal.

Method: The study population consisted of cases referred to and delivered at Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre, diagnosed between January 1993 and December 2001. The diagnosis of severe hydrocephalus was based on a lateral ventricular atrium diameter > or =15 mm in at least one hemisphere.

Results: Sixty cases were ascertained: 28 with NTD (group 1) and 32 without NTD (group 2). The groups were similar in terms of maternal and child variables at birth and hospitalization days during the 1st year of life. The mortality (including intrauterine deaths and deaths of babies with malformations incompatible with life that characterize a very poor prognosis) until 1 year of age was 36% in group 1 and 59% in group 2 (p = 0.077). The rate of cardiac malformations was higher in the group without NTD (p = 0.015). The length of hospital stay after birth (1st admission) was significantly higher in the group with NTD (p = 0.007).

Conclusions: The morbidity was higher in the group with NTD, possibly due to the higher number of surgical interventions in the central nervous system. However, the mortality was higher in the group without NTD, possibly due to the presence of other associated malformations, especially congenital heart disease. Further studies should focus on neurological function and quality of life of the children and their families at the end of the 1st year and after 2 or 6 years of age.