An understanding of cellular signalling from a systems-based approach has to be robust to assess the effects of point mutations in component proteins. Outcomes of these perturbations should be predictable in terms of downstream response, otherwise a holistic interpretation of biological processes or disease states cannot be obtained. Two single, proximal point mutations (S252W and P253R) in the extracellular region of FGFR2 (fibroblast growth factor receptor 2) prolong growth factor engagement resulting in dramatically different intracellular phenotypes. Following ligand stimulation, the wild-type receptor undergoes rapid endocytosis into lysosomes, whereas (SW)FGFR2 (the S252W FGFR2 point mutation) and (PR)FGFR2 (the P253R FGFR2 point mutation) remain on the cell membrane for an extended period of time, modifying protein recruitment and elevating downstream ERK (extracellular-signal-regulated kinase) phosphorylation. FLIM (fluorescent lifetime imaging microscopy) reveals that direct interaction of FRS2 (FGFR substrate 2) with wild-type receptor occurs primarily at the vesicular membrane, whereas the interaction with the P253R receptor occurs exclusively at the plasma membrane. These observations suggest that the altered FRS2 recruitment by the mutant receptors results in an abnormal cellular signalling mechanism. In the present study these profound intracellular phenotypes resulting from extracellular receptor modification reveal a new level of complexity which will challenge a systems biology interpretation.