Human DNA ligase I (hLigI) participates in DNA replication and excision repair via an interaction with proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), a DNA sliding clamp. In addition, hLigI interacts with and is inhibited by replication factor C (RFC), the clamp loader complex that loads PCNA onto DNA. Here we show that a mutant version of hLigI, which mimics the hyperphosphorylated M-phase form of hLigI, does not interact with and is not inhibited by RFC, demonstrating that inhibition of ligation is dependent upon the interaction between hLigI and RFC. To examine the biological relevance of hLigI phosphorylation, we isolated derivatives of the hLigI-deficient cell line 46BR.1G1 that stably express mutant versions of hLigI in which four serine residues phosphorylated in vivo were replaced with either alanine or aspartic acid. The cell lines expressing the phosphorylation site mutants of hLigI exhibited a dramatic reduction in proliferation and DNA synthesis and were also hypersensitive to DNA damage. The dominant-negative effects of the hLigI phosphomutants on replication and repair are due to the activation of cellular senescence, presumably because of DNA damage arising from replication abnormalities. Thus, appropriate phosphorylation of hLigI is critical for its participation in DNA replication and repair.