Molecular genetic analysis of AKR1C2-4 and HSD17B6 genes in subjects 46,XY with hypospadias

Background: The formation of the male urethra depends to enzyme-mediated testosterone (T) conversion into 5α-dihydrotestosterone (DHT). Two metabolic pathways could be operating in the fetal testis to synthesize androgens: 1) the "classic" route (T→DHT) mediated by SRD5A2 and 2) a "backdoor" pathway in which DHT is synthesized by aldo-keto reductase family 1, member C2 (AKR1C2), AKR1C3, and AKR1C4 enzymes without formation of a T intermediate.

Objective: We studied four genes of the "backdoor" pathway in karyotypic males with hypospadias to ascertain whether gene defects in AKRs impair urethral DHT formation that result in hypospadias.

Design and patients: The coding regions of the AKR1C2-4 and HSD17B6 genes were analyzed by PCR-SSCP and sequencing in a cohort of 25 Mexican patients (0.3-9 year-old-children) with 46,XY-hypospadias. Chi-squared tests was performed to evaluate the distribution of genotypes, alleles, and the Hardy-Weinberg (H-W) equilibrium. The effect of the genetic variants was investigated by in silico studies.

Results: Screening studies revealed distinct genotypic patterns at different exons of AKR1C2-4 whereas HSD17B6 presented a wild-type sequence. The DNA analyses detected two synonymous variants (c.327C>T, c.666T>C/unreported) in AKR1C2. The AKR1C3 had two variants (c.15C>G, c.230A>G), two unreported variants (c.538T>C, c.596G>A), and one silent variant (c.312G>A). Two variants (c.434C>G, c.931C>G) were identified in AKR1C4. All variants were in H-W equilibrium without structural changes.

Discussion: Hypospadias have been associated with defects that alter androgen biosynthesis in the human fetal testis, specifically 5α-DHT. We selected four candidate genes involved in the "backdoor" pathway for the formation of 5α-DHT. Molecular assays of the AKR1C2, AKR1C3, and AKR1C4 genes revealed a total of nine genetic single nucleotide variants. Several variants in the AKR1C genes have been associated with a variety of human pathologies. However, our studies suggest that active steroid biosynthesis via AKR1C might not be involved in hypospadias. Additionally, genetic research suggests a low involvement in the "backdoor" 5α-DHT pathway during human sexual development, specifically, the differentiation of male external genitalia.

Conclusion: These results indicate that substitutions in AKR1C2-4 are polymorphisms and all genetic variants lacks deleterious significant association with hypospadias. The data suggest that inactivating mutations in the AKR1C2-4 and HSD17B6 genes are an infrequent cause of hypospadias, which might weaken the contribution of the "backdoor" pathway to embryonic urethral masculinization.