Early vs late surgical treatment of radial instability of the thumb metacarpophalangeal joint. A retrospective cohort study

There is no clear evidence in the literature whether treating thumb radial collateral ligament (RCL) injury in the acute phase improves outcome. The purpose of the present study was to compare the clinical and radiological results of RCL repair in acute and chronic settings. Fourteen patients were included. Clinical range of motion (ROM) of the thumb, Kapandji score and radiological parameters were compared pre- and post-operatively to the contralateral uninjured thumb (control group) to evaluate the results of the surgical technique. Patients were then divided into two groups according to early versus late repair and outcomes were compared between the two groups and the control group. Preoperatively, mean spontaneous angle between first metacarpal (M1) and proximal phalanx (P1) (spontaneous M1P1 angle), ulnar stress M1P1 angle, ROM and Kapandji score differed significantly between injured and uninjured sides. Postoperatively these parameters for the injured side improved, reaching values similar to those on the uninjured side, especially with acute phase treatment; late treatment also tended to provide clinical improvement in ROM, Kapandji score and ulnar stress angle, but with significant improvement only for spontaneous deviation of the thumb. This study showed the late and immediate repair of the RCL of the thumb both gave good results, with slightly better outcome with acute phase repair. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, Level III.