Protoporphyria is an autosomal dominant disease in man in which protoporphyrin accumulated because of a defect in heme synthase (ferrochelatase) activity. A disease has been described in cattle that has the same manifestations as does the human disease. We measured heme synthase activity in sonicates of cultured skin fibroblasts and whole liver homogenates from animals with protoporphyria, their unaffected parents, and normal cattle in order to examine the mode of inheritance and compare it with human protoporphyria. The mean activity (+/- SEM) in fibroblasts from the three groups was 2.0 +/- 0.4, 47 +/- 12, and 149 +/- 10 pmol heme formed/mg protein per hr, respectively, consistent with autosomal recessive inheritance. Similarly, the levels of heme synthase activity in livers of the parents were intermediate to those of normal animals and of animals with protoporphyria. When compared with normal human fibroblasts and liver, the specific activity of heme synthase in normal bovine tissue was significantly higher. These studies indicate that manifestations of protoporphyria do not occur in cattle unless the animal is homozygous for the gene defect, whereas in humans, the heterozygous condition is sufficient. This is probably because the specific activity of heme synthase in cells of heterozygous animals is not reduced to a level that significantly alters heme metabolism.